Skip to main content
Tasty Grilled Chicken Sandwich

American Food in Plymouth

Grilled and fried sandwiches join seafood dishes in a selection of American food at The Tasty in Plymouth, MA, available for pickup.

Order online

Sandwiches

Fish Sandwich

$18.00

Crispy cod sandwich with lettuce, jalapeño relish, herbs, and chili mayo.

“We had the best lunch at The Tasty! Maria was a super attentive server who was happy to help with everything. Well all had sandwiches, of which the fish was a fan favourite! Arguably the best fish sandwich we’ve ever tasted. All local produce and clearly made with love and care. Thanks very much 🫶🏼”

Chicken

Fish

Seafood Chowder

$12.00

Creamy chowder with clams and cod; crackers come on the side.

“Our first visit there was for lunch, which they told us they had just resumed after a long hiatus. It was all just right. We ordered cups of the seafood chowder and were surprised that they were very generous portions of EXCELLENT soup served in nice antique blue china type bowls. The sandwiches, salad and fries were all first-rate as well. Nice touch is the house-made sodas. Very tasty and not too sweet. Heartily recommend.”

Cornbread

Find Something Special at The Tasty

The Tasty's American food spans double-dipped fried chicken with spicy mayo and pickles, braised beef with horseradish cream and cheddar, and crisp buffalo cauliflower with rice cakes and blue cheese.

Cornbread comes with honey butter and flaky salt; Wings pair harissa, yuzu, and honey with fried garlic and scallions. Seafood Chowder combines clams, cod, and cream, with crackers served on the side.

Visit The Tasty in Plymouth, MA for dine-in, or order pickup or delivery. Pastrami Reuben Sandwich layers house-smoked pastrami, Gruyère, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on marble rye.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular American food options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Wings — Chicken wings feature harissa, yuzu, honey, fried garlic, and scallions for a tangy, sweet, savory flavor combination.
  • Garlic Chili Wings — These grilled chicken wings are crisped and finished with miso butter, garlic, and a hot sauce made with pickled chile.
  • Oma's Carrot Cake — This carrot cake is listed as nut-free, though the menu does not specify its frosting or additional ingredients.
  • Tasty Grilled Chicken Sandwich — Grilled chicken breast comes with bacon, Cheddar, pickled red onion, ranch, and lettuce, plus your choice of fries or house salad.
  • Cornbread — Cornbread made with Plymouth Grist Mill cornmeal is served with honey butter and flaky salt for a sweet-savory finish.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for american food throughout the Plymouth area. Order your american food online for convenient pickup or delivery.